Countless artists have covered 'Baby It's Cold Outside' over the decades, and the song's enduring popularity is no mystery. The tune boasts an undeniably charming melody, and plenty of listeners can relate to the classic scenario of blaming brutal winter weather to dodge an underwhelming evening. But there's a catch — the fellow in the song isn't simply hoping she'll linger a moment longer. He's actively pressuring her to remain, seemingly intoxicated by her presence and unwilling to let her walk out the door. Hold on, what? Oh, right — despite endless versions floating around out there, actually paying attention to the words reveals something far more unsettling than a sweet seasonal duet. The track crosses well past mildly disturbing into territory Bill Cosby himself might have treated as gospel.
Need a refresher? Here's a lyric video that brings you up to speed:
Listen closely and you'll catch the gentleman making aggressive attempts to convince his companion not to head home, while she repeatedly insists she really must leave. Then comes the bombshell: she wonders aloud, "Say, what's in this drink?" That line alone stops you in your tracks — seriously, how did a cheerful holiday standard slip through with a lyric that practically references a date rape substance? Seriously, WHAT?! For all its delightful, upbeat musical charm, the song harbors deeply troubling undercurrents that don't merely blur the issue of consent — they completely erase it. Once audiences began catching wind of these controversial verses, satirical reworkings started sprouting up all across the internet…
And without fail, every holiday season, the tune gets dragged across Twitter…
Given all this damning evidence pointing to serious issues with 'Baby It's Cold Outside', how could anyone possibly mount a defense of it? Well, wonder no more — a defender has emerged, one who brings far deeper insight into the historical era when the song was originally composed and recorded. Check out this compelling defense of 'Baby It's Cold Outside', which raises several thought-provoking and unexpected arguments. And yes — it even tackles that notorious spiked-drink line!:
(Source)
Now that you've heard this defense laid out, do you believe 'Baby It's Cold Outside' should remain a permanent fixture of the holiday canon, or is it time to retire the tune because it's unsettling from every possible angle? Drop your take @Smosh!
